Before Bluegrass: The Roots of Old-Time American Music
Updated: Oct 9
For my second blog entry, I'd like to explore some of the earliest American musical traditions I've encountered through my time playing with and learning from Dr. Colonel Clinton Davis. I played guitar regularly with him for several years leading up to the pandemic. These days, I play with him a handful of times a year, including at lectures at San Diego State University and annually at a church for the Blessing of the Animals service in Hillcrest. When I started playing with him I got a Martin guitar. No pickup, no frills, just a basic Orchestra model guitar, a smaller-bodied acoustic guitar. It’s still my favorite acoustic guitar and it was recently set up by Danny at West Guitarworks. I highly recommend his shop for any guitar repair and setup needs.
When most people think of early American music they tend to think of “bluegrass”, but in fact bluegrass developed around World War II partly out of what is known as “old-time music.” Old-time music basically goes back as far as Europeans began settlement in North America in the 1600s, although the music developed over several centuries. As far as I understand, the simple definition of old-time music is music from Europe combined with music from Africa that was melded together in North America. At its core, old-time music is the western European fiddle and west African banjo. Additional instruments include the mandolin and guitar. Old-time groups are called “string bands.” The fiddle will play the melody and the banjo plays the rhythm as well as some melody. Sometimes the mandolin may play the melody as well. Collective playing and repeated melodies are more characteristic than the individual solo breaks of bluegrass. It’s also music intended primarily for dancing and storytelling.
Of all the facts and history I’ve learned from Clinton Davis, what I find most helpful and interesting is understanding the different ideas about melody that are involved in old-time music, and mostly in old-time fiddling. One distinction Clint makes is that many European melodies have arcs, meaning they go up high and then down low and flow like a ribbon in a relatively dramatic and full-range fashion. He describes many African melodies as tending to stay in one spot, moving up and down in a tighter fashion and focusing more on groove and rhythm. Both of these elements are combined in the melodies of old-time music. At this point, I think you can broaden the definition of old-time music as a mix of European and African instruments, melodies, and rhythms.
As I said, I’ve been a part of several lectures at San Diego State University on old-time music. One question that comes up a lot is: what about upright bass, and isn’t that part of old-time music? The simple answer is it wasn't a defining instrument of many early fiddle-and-banjo ensembles. Today, old-time string bands definitely incorporate the upright bass but it was not common until the 20th century, generally after World War I.
Interestingly, other early American musical traditions found creative ways to provide bass accompaniment. Jug bands, which became popular in parts of the urban South, particularly Louisville, Kentucky, used empty jugs that musicians blew into to produce low, rhythmic tones. These groups were largely African American and were more closely associated with early blues, ragtime, and popular entertainment, including medicine shows and vaudeville, than with Appalachian old-time music.
One possible explanation for the absence of upright basses in early rural string bands is availability. Instruments were often handmade locally up in the hills of Appalachia and an upright bass would have been difficult and expensive to construct or transport into remote areas. Another alternative was the washtub bass, a homemade instrument that became associated with jug bands and other folk traditions.
Another common question is about drums and percussion, and why they aren't typically part of old-time string bands. Most people are surprised to learn how modern the drum set actually is. Though drums and percussion have been around for thousands of years, the modern drum set didn't begin taking shape until the early 1900s. The bass drum pedal became commercially available around 1909, followed by early versions of the hi-hat in the 1920s. By the 1930s, the familiar combination of bass drum, snare, toms, and cymbals had become more established. Traditional old-time string bands, however, generally relied on the fiddle, banjo, and other stringed instruments to provide both melody and rhythm, without needing a drummer.
As American music continued to evolve into the 20th century, new styles and approaches to playing began to emerge. Around the turn of the 20th century, ragtime became an enormously popular form of American music and an important precursor to jazz. Its syncopated rhythms also influenced other styles of popular music. Meanwhile, banjo players were developing increasingly sophisticated picking techniques. In the 1930s, a young Earl Scruggs developed his distinctive three-finger approach to the banjo, using a thumb pick and two finger picks to create flowing, rapid-fire patterns of notes. When Scruggs joined Bill Monroe's Blue Grass Boys in 1945, his playing helped establish the sound that would become known as bluegrass.
Another common question is, what's the difference between old-time music and bluegrass? There are several answers. While old-time music often emphasizes collective playing and repeated melodies, bluegrass places greater emphasis on individual solos, improvisation, and instrumental virtuosity. Bluegrass bands also commonly feature upright bass and sometimes dobro, along with the fiddle, banjo, guitar, and mandolin.
Playing old-time music and learning from Clint has deepened my understanding of American music and made me think about melodies, the roles of instruments in an ensemble, and where bluegrass and country music all come from. When I first started learning tunes with Clint, I was introduced to the music of Foghorn Stringband, one of the premier contemporary groups playing old-time music and fiddle tunes. In 2021, we got to open for Reeb and Caleb from Foghorn Stringband at Verbatim Books in San Diego, which was a really cool moment to meet them and share a night of playing with them. Clint played some songs they had not heard and it was neat to show each other old-time songs we both were not familiar with. So many of the songs Clint has researched are rarely recorded or widely known. Through his study of the music and his roots in Kentucky, he's been able to bring these forgotten tunes back to life. To be a part of that has been very rewarding.
Here are some videos of Clinton Davis, pre-pandemic, when I regularly backed him up in the trio.



Comments